My testimony to the Assembly and Senate Committees on the EDA Bill A4/S3295 - 12/19/2020
My testimony to the Assembly and Senate Committees on the EDA Bill A4/S3295 which is set to allocate almost $15 billion in funding for tax credits which have no economic literature showing they work and the bill will go from first public posting to final vote in less than 120 hours. Call your Legislators, tell them to vote NO.
Assembly, left ear
This process is, a failure of democracy, full stop.
There are only 2 public hearings on a 200+ page bill, and they’re happening at the same time, stretching residents and advocates and ensuring that opposition is diluted.
Tim Sullivan mentioned that the old program had no caps, but the quote caps unquote being proposed are almost 2 billion dollars a year. In what world, is 2 billion dollars a year reasonably described as a cap? That’s many multiples of anything the old bill was used to give out.
A 15 minute break was taken for members to familiarize themselves with 142 pages of amendments to a Bill with more than 200 pages, so you could catch up on the amendments. Why? Why do we need to pass this bill on Monday? Why can’t you review and understand this legislation on a timeline befitting the enormous price tag of this legislation?
This bill introduces some good oversight, transparency, and legal changes. At least we think it does. It’s hard to tell when you have had 24 hours to read 200+ pages. But do we all have amnesia? Have we forgotten 3 detailed reports about how the EDA programs had failed NJ tax payers? Have we forgotten that economist after economist from all corners of the political spectrum have stated that there is very little evidence these credits work and rarely if ever create a net return to the state?
Please do not move this bill. Please vote no on the floor if it moves out of committee. We need a bill to agree with surrounding states to forever abandon tax incentives, not have a race to the bottom.
Thank you.
Senate, right ear
This process is, a failure of democracy, full stop.
You were asking here where Tim Sullivan is, he was in the Assembly because the only other public hearing on this 11 billion dollar bill is happening at the same time in the Assembly. Why does the need to vote for this on Monday, override the ability for advocates, and even the head of the EDA to actually attend both hearings from end to end? Why are our 2 public hearings on this bill happening at the same time, stretching residents and advocates and ensuring that opposition is diluted?
Former Senator Lesniak mentioned a social justice aspect of this bill. If that’s true, let’s request, and wait for, a racial impact statement to understand how giving 11 billion dollars to corporations should reasonably be expected to benefit our historically oppressed racial groups.
Chairman Sarlo mentioned this bill has been worked on for 2 years. That’s great for those of you in the room in those meetings. Your constituents have seen this bill for 24 hours before this hearing, and it will be 1 full business day before it sees a floor vote. There is no reason this cannot slow down.
It was noted our state is not affordable, how does giving 11 billion away to corporations make it more affordable for NJ residents? How does doing that within a week serve NJ residents?
This bill introduces some good oversight, transparency, and legal changes. At least we think it does. It’s hard to tell when you have had 24 hours to read 200+ pages. But do we all have amnesia? Have we forgotten 3 detailed reports about how the EDA programs had failed NJ tax payers? Have we forgotten that economist after economist from all corners of the political spectrum have stated that there is very little evidence these credits work and rarely if ever they create a net return for the state and it’s residents?
Thank you
Add a comment: