Public Comment 9/9/2020
Item K37 is to approve spending to purchase new firearms for the Department of Corrections. We as residents have been calling to defund the police, and really the entire mass incarceration apparatus, reflecting a desire to shift that spending to proactively address the root causes of the vast disparities in our society and County. Investing in education, food security, social workers, healthcare, mental health, and drug treatment instead of buying more weapons, training more officers, and enforcing our existing laws, which were born out of racism. This particular contract is not for very much money, but I ask you to start thinking of each of these things within the larger context.
On the street outside your office and the headquarters for much of the County Government are the words “Abolish white supremacy.” Some of you could tell the stories, the deep personal wounds left behind by interactions with law enforcement, with banks, with exposure of family members to the criminal justice system, and I don’t pretend to speak for you. So could many residents of Newark, who live under the control of a police force trying to reform, not voluntarily, but rather under a Federal Consent Decree. But we can’t chip away at the edges, we need to be willing to commit to large scale changes in our thinking, policies, and where and why we allocate funds.
George Floyd’s daughter, providing the brave, unfiltered voice that comes naturally to a 6-year-old, looked out over the protests in response to her father’s death in awe of his impact and said, “Daddy changed the world.” That feels true, it feels different this time, but the changes that need to be made won’t happen without our help, and more specifically, your help.
Sherrilyn Ifill, president of the NAACP Legal Defense Fund has said “What are you prepared to dismantle? What are you prepared to build?” I pose that question to the Board. You are Essex County’s Builders. Not only at the County level, but in each municipality as you allocate resources to encourage each local government to move and build along with you. You have approved the money to build a new Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. building, which will include the courtrooms where jurors from Essex County will be charged with dispensing justice. What will that justice look like? What injustices will you commit to dismantling as part of that building process?
On K42, the text isn’t posted online, but the summary seems to indicate you’ll be voting on whether to support healthcare as a human right, specifically Medicare for All and what would be a test run for the future of healthcare under the current pandemic. I’d highly encourage you to support that Resolution. And a reminder that currently the population of ECCF is a group we are legally required to provide healthcare for. We should be looking at what the medical care in that environment looks like and what copays can be waived or refunded for COVID related treatment. I’m also excited to see that the Civilian Task Force will be holding 3 public meetings specifically on medical care and I’d encourage the public and the Commissioners to attend.
Thank you for your support of the prior Resolution calling for an end to private prisons in NJ. Incarceration is one of the government’s most solemn responsibilities. When we choose to put someone in jail or prison we are agreeing as a society to be responsible for every aspect of their lives. That includes ensuring fair and humane treatment for all inmates, which can only be achieved through an open and transparent system. Private prisons abdicate that responsibility by turning incarceration into a for-profit exercise with limited to no transparency.
However it’s not just private prisons. I had previously asked via email for the COVID antibody testing policy for ECCF and was told by the County Executive’s Chief of Staff that it was covered by HIPAA. I asked for the legal justification under which a policy for a facility was being withheld from the public under a law that primarily directs the handling of individual’s health records and was told that my question had been answered, and I got no further responses. So I’m forced to ask here, requesting formal response:
1. What is the COVID antibody testing policy for the ECCF?
2. Are inmates/detainees tested only upon arrival at the facility or is there regularly scheduled ongoing testing during their time there?
3. Is there any follow up testing if the original test indicates active/recent infection?
4. Is there any follow up testing if the original test indicates no antibodies of any kind?
5. If that policy is different for prisoners of ICE, US Marshals, State, or County what are those differences.
6. If it is still being maintained that ECCF policies are subject to HIPAA, please provide the legal justification behind that stance.
In the lens of building and dismantling, I look forward to a Resolution calling for our State Legislature to pass marijuana decriminalization, an important step in meaningfully dismantling the legal framework that drives thousands of arrests in our County every year. That Resolution should also call on our County Prosecutor to no longer prosecute those possession charges, and notify all municipal departments and the Sheriff that arrests for those offenses will not be prosecuted any longer, no matter the timeline of the Legislative action. We also need a Resolution supporting the sentencing reform bill, because our Jail and the state prisons exacerbated and worsened racial and economic disparity even before COVID made any jail sentence a potential death sentence.
Add a comment: