We keep us safe - A failure by Cornell's Leadership
Cornell has failed the student allegedly raped by those seven men at Chi Phi in October 2024. Cornell has failed her. Cornell has failed us.

Cornell has failed the student allegedly raped by those seven men at Chi Phi in October 2024. Cornell has failed her. Cornell has failed us.
I wrote “I’m not Brett Kavanaugh and that’s not an accomplishment“ in 2018, composed mostly in my head as I drove, alone with my thoughts. Then a quick a brain dump through my fingertips into the keyboard in a fit of anger.
As we approach 10 years later, we still have so much work to do. Cornell Administrators decided that 7 newly minted Brett Kavanaughs were more important than keeping women safe on their campus. All the women on campus, less important than those 7 future Bretts. Just one woman should have been enough to justify a line in the sand, making an example of the “frat boys,” but for those Administrators it wasn’t.
Though they’re not boys, right? At least in so much as their victim was a “young woman” not a “girl.” A child? If we give the perpetrators that protection, why don’t we also give it to the victim?
I went to a rich, white, all boys, private high school because my great aunt left me money to pay for it. There were plenty of good people there. There was also a few Brett Kavanaughs. …
…
I had grandmothers who didn’t take crap from anyone and grandfathers who respected them. I had uncles raised to respect women. I was raised to respect women. My parents were equals. They both were responsible for child care. They both worked. They both shaped me to be the person I am today.
I went to parties where people were drinking underage, I decided not to. I managed to laugh with my friends without degrading the women around us. I managed to not sexually assault someone just because I was a boy and boys will be boys. I never had to worry about walking alone, getting a ride in a pouring rain, who I made eye contact with or talked to. Who might find me on social media.
I’ve made mistakes. I’ve hopefully adequately made amends for those mistakes.
…
I have a daughter and she’s not growing up in Brett Kavanaugh’s world. Because I’m going to help amazing, strong, smart women burn that world down. Enough is enough.
I’m not Brett Kavanaugh and that’s not an accomplishment • Buttondown
I could have been Brett Kavanaugh. The fact that I’m not is not something I deserve praise for. It’s just that I’m a remotely decent human being, because that’s who I was raised to be.
But who are the adults in the room? Certainly not the Cornell Administrators, who refused to take this violent, disgusting event seriously. Or maybe they thought banning the frat was all they had to do. But that’s not what we mean when we say the problems are systemic. The same Administrators who went after students doing pro-Palestine organizing, maybe they were distracted, one would think those two offenses should have held clearly different priorities.
The student editors at the Cornell Sun showed far more bravery than the Cornell Administrators who supposedly are there to protect and guide them. Editors, mostly women, who put their names and reputations behind their values. Who stood up and said, no, this is wrong. More than the Administrators bothered to do.
You should read the whole thing, but I tried to include the parts that were most powerful to me. In some ways, the headline itself is the most damning, and unifying line. I want to particularly draw your eye to how, even in their need to follow journalistic and legal best practices, the use of allegedly is not used to excuse, or second guess, or absolve. It is used to excoriate, to attack, and to burn.
So we cannot allow the victim here to reframed to be the men who might be held accountable for their heinous behavior. The victim is the brave women continuing to pursue some shred of accountability. The Editorial Board at the Cornell Sun are being incredible allies, though for some of them, it’s the only protection they’re being given.
So I’m sharing this to help them burn down Brett’s world, at Cornell and beyond.
Cornell Won’t, We Will
By Editor-in-Chief Sophia Dasser ’28, Associate Editor Sophia Romanov Imber ’28 and Opinion Editors Zara Cheek ’28 and Rayen Zhou ’29
https://www.cornellsun.com/article/2026/09/editorial-cornell-won-t-we-willMatthew Ingalls. Jonathan Newell. Winston Lee. Gillio Lopes. Diego Sarabia. Scott Norris. Scott Kretzschmar.
These are the names of the seven men named as defendants in a civil complaint filed on Sept. 14 alleging they drugged and gang raped a Cornell student, identified as Jane Doe, in the Chi Phi house in October 2024.
…
…The Faculty Senate, voting 80-16 in November 2025, held that interim suspensions should cease when the risk of harm ceases. For the men to be back on campus, either the danger passed at some identifiable moment, and thus this community is owed an account of what changed, or it did not and the suspensions were lifted anyway.
…
Tackling sexual assault as an academic matter — complete with its charts and facts and figures — offers no respite to the victims who have undergone physical and mental abuse. Academic “solutions,” like the essays, allegedly offered to the defendants to mitigate their suspensions, is belittling to the severity of the crime. It offers no concrete, feasible solutions beyond the usual passivities of “communication” and “understanding” that assume we live in a world of saints and angels. …
…
This is not a dark chapter in Cornell’s history, it’s a morbid pattern, only rectified with thorough criminal investigations in the hands of parties independent of the University — the Ithaca Police Department and the Tompkins County district attorney. As for Cornell, administrators have allowed the idea that enough ambiguity, enough he-said-she-said, enough familial connections, enough money will allow you to get off scot-free. …
…
In Cornell’s own words, in the very letter it published on Nov. 26, 2024 — “Only those who perpetrate sexual violence benefit from its concealment.”
We refuse for this victim to be reduced to just another story. Cornell has failed to protect its students. Cornell has failed to address the growing issue of sexual assault on campus with its pathetic task force. Cornell has failed the student allegedly raped by those seven men at Chi Phi in October 2024. Cornell has failed her. Cornell has failed us.
To Matthew Ingalls, Jonathan Newell, Winston Lee, Gillio Lopes, Diego Sarabia, Scott Norris and Scott Kretzschmar: We know who you are and we refuse to let you benefit from this University's concealment.
The Cornell Daily Sun’s Editorial Board is a collaborative team composed of Editor-in-Chief Sophia Dasser ’28, Associate Editor Sophia Romanov Imber ’28 and Opinion Editors Zara Cheek ’28 and Rayen Zhou ’29.
Add a comment: