Civilian Oversight at Essex County Jail Public Comment 09/25/2019
Civilian Oversight at Essex County Jail Public Comment 09/25/2019
Civilian Oversight at Essex County Jail Public Comment 09/25/2019
I am here again to speak about the need for Civilian Oversight of the jail. Since the last meeting there has been yet another report of officers assaulting a detainee in the facility. So my question to which I am requesting a written response: Which Freeholders have read the incident reports about the May 17th incident?
Many of the copies of those jail reports obtained for the Gothomist reporting are largely illegible but still redacted. This shows that the originals were clear, so they knew what to redact, but little effort went into providing readable copies to the media or they were intentionally made impossible to read. That kind of behavior indicates an environment where no one is worried about following the laws around producing documents, so why would we expect them to worry about following other laws or rules within the facility.
In one of the legible documents jail staff wrote, in an official disciplinary report, that the inmate’s infraction was, among other things, being responsible for “disrupting officers breaks.” “Disrupting officers breaks” was written in an official infraction report by a Sergeant working in the facility that day, Sgt. Lopez. Then that document was signed off on by their Lieutenant, Lt. Wise. Imagine the message that sends to everyone else when not only do you not get told “haha, now rewrite the form,” but to have your supervisor write it and their supervisor sign off on it as is. And who knows what was written in the other documents that were seemingly intentionally scanned so poorly as to be unreadable.
But whatever they wrote on those other pages, the punishment doled out for the incident was to place the detainee in solitary confinement. A non-criminal, civil detainee was placed in solitary confinement. Placed in solitary confinement for at least 5 days but apparently 30 days. Placed in solitary confinement for 30 days, the longest allowed under the jail’s rules for ICE detainees.
And before being placed in solitary, he was beaten: punched, kneed, hit with a broomstick, and had an officer step on his genitals. Many of his injuries were confirmed at University Hospital.
And I would say he was allegedly beaten, but the Sergeant’s report doesn’t say he allegedly disrupted break. Because when you have power with no accountability you don’t have to use words like allegedly.
These are documents from one case, of a handful reported by the media, of a handful that have been investigated by outside entities. The prosecutor’s office only recently reopened this case when the media started digging into it. There must be hundreds if not thousands of similar occurrences.
I will repeat this every time, these are Joe D’s prisoners, your prisoners, our prisoners, my prisoners. We need strong, legally empowered, civilian oversight of the jail in line with the ACLU recommendations.
Thank you.
Add a comment: