Civilian Oversight at Essex County Jail Public Comment 10/23/2019
Civilian Oversight at Essex County Jail Public Comment 10/23/2019
Civilian Oversight at Essex County Jail Public Comment 10/23/2019
Thank you to the Freeholders and Administration for putting forward an ordinance that is a first step in the process of instituting Civilian Oversight of the County Jail. I have some questions that I would appreciate responses to so as to better inform the public before it comes up on second reading.
- 3.A.2 the chair holds a great deal of power, what is the rationale for having them be selected by the County Executive, not elected within the Task Force?
- 3.A.3 the Executive Director has a lot of implicit power, like writing bylaws, and explicit power, performing review of internal documents. What is the rationale for that position being appointed by the County Executive and not requiring advice and consent of the Freeholders or input from the community?
- 3.A.4 will resumes and other information about nominees be shared with the public when provided to the Freeholders? Or will we have to OPRA for them, not having them in hand before the Freeholders have already advised and consented?
- 3.B.2, would that be understood to preclude any Essex County politician or Municipal Leadership position in a municipality that has received County funds? What about non-profit boards or leadership who have received County funds as grants or for services they provide?
- 5.B.6 Tracking retaliation or intimidation is a great step, what about notifications or monthly reporting of additional incidents that involve ECCF staff that have prior or ongoing complaints against them?
- 5.B.7 What if the retaliation or intimidation is being done by someone who is employed by Essex County outside of ECCF staff?
- 5.C.1 What policies and procedures from ECCF or ICE are likely to limit information gathering? What policies were being thought of when that carve out was added?
- 5.D.1 The Chair controlling access to the facility by any Task Force member puts an incredible amount of power in that position. Why not share that responsibility among a subcommittee?
- 5.F.4 Executive Director has special document review privileges, it would be much stronger to have a full sub-committee empowered to perform that task as the Executive Director is already extremely powerful and the only position appointed solely at the discretion of the County Exec. Those members could have all whatever additional training or confidentiality agreement required to do that work effectively and uphold whatever standards are agreed to.
- 6.A.5 why “may make the reports available” instead of must or should? Any reports created by this Task Force are to provide oversight of the facility and therefore should be required to be publicly released.
- 6.C Why are the annual and emergency reports not explicitly guaranteed to be public documents?
- 8.A.1 You and the Administration are establishing this Task Force. So why have the members, including two ultra powerful positions among them directly appointed by the County Executive, decide if the Task Force should disband? They could just resign if they feel it’s not of value any more. And given the schedule of initial appointments, many who served will not even be around to participate in the first self-evaluation.
9.A.2 Does the prompt referral indicate after all of the investigations that are noted to keep the Task Force from starting their investigation? Or will the Task Force be notified promptly, and then wait to start their investigation?
These are Joe D’s prisoners, your prisoners, our prisoners, my prisoners and maybe soon, the Task Force's prisoners so please act accordingly.
Thank you.
Add a comment: